Skip to content

Four Things You’re Doing Wrong When it Comes to Managing High Performers

High performers are invaluable assets to any organization, but managing them effectively requires a different approach.

By WOI+ Editorial Team

High performers can propel a team to new heights, driving innovation, efficiency, and excellence. However, managing these exceptional individuals requires more than just standard leadership tactics. Many leaders unknowingly make mistakes that can lead to disengagement, frustration, or even turnover among their top talent. By understanding and addressing these common missteps, you can create an environment where high performers thrive and contribute their best work.

1. Micromanaging Instead of Trusting

One of the most significant mistakes managers make is micromanaging their high performers. These individuals are often self-motivated, capable, and require a level of autonomy to excel. Constant oversight and control can stifle their creativity and initiative, leading to frustration and disengagement.

Trust is essential. Provide clear goals and expectations, but give your high performers the freedom to determine how to achieve them. Encourage them to take ownership of their projects, make decisions, and experiment with new approaches. Trusting them to manage their work not only empowers them but also fosters a sense of responsibility and commitment.

Consider an example: Emma, a top software developer, consistently delivered high-quality code ahead of schedule. Her manager, however, insisted on approving every minor change, attending every meeting, and dictating the smallest details of her tasks. This micromanagement stifled Emma’s creativity and led her to feel undervalued. Eventually, she left the company for a competitor who offered her the autonomy she craved.

To avoid this scenario, shift from a directive to a supportive management style. Regularly check in to provide guidance and support, but avoid unnecessary control over day-to-day activities. High performers value the opportunity to demonstrate their expertise and should be trusted to do so.

2. Failing to Provide Sufficient Challenge and Growth Opportunities

High performers thrive on challenge and growth. If they feel their work has become routine or lacks opportunities for development, they may become disengaged and seek new challenges elsewhere. It’s a mistake to assume that because they are performing well, they are content with the status quo.

Offer challenging projects that push their boundaries and allow them to develop new skills. Regularly discuss their career aspirations and create a development plan that includes stretch assignments, training opportunities, and mentorship. By investing in their growth, you show that you value their contributions and are committed to their long-term success.

For example, consider Daniel, a high-performing financial analyst who consistently delivered insightful reports. His work, however, became repetitive, and he yearned for new challenges. His manager recognized this and assigned him to lead a cross-functional project, providing him with new learning opportunities and a platform to demonstrate leadership skills. This not only reinvigorated Daniel’s enthusiasm but also added significant value to the company.

3. Overlooking Recognition and Feedback

High performers often receive less feedback than their peers because managers assume they know they are doing well. However, these individuals also need regular recognition and constructive feedback to stay motivated and improve.

Recognition should be specific and meaningful. Celebrate their achievements and highlight how their work has positively impacted the team or organization. Constructive feedback is equally important; high performers appreciate insights that can help them refine their skills and achieve even greater success. Make feedback a regular part of your interactions to ensure they feel valued and supported.

Take the case of Sophie, a marketing executive who consistently exceeded her targets. Despite her success, her manager rarely acknowledged her achievements or provided feedback. Over time, Sophie felt her efforts were unnoticed, leading to disengagement. When her new manager started recognizing her contributions and offering constructive feedback, Sophie’s motivation and performance soared.

4. Ignoring the Importance of a Positive Work Environment

Even the most talented individuals can struggle in a toxic work environment. High performers are particularly sensitive to negative dynamics, as they often have high standards and a strong sense of integrity. An environment characterized by poor communication, lack of collaboration, or unfair practices can quickly demotivate them.

Foster a positive and inclusive culture. Promote open communication, encourage teamwork, and address any issues of conflict or unfairness promptly. Show that you care about their well-being by supporting work-life balance and offering flexibility. A positive work environment not only retains high performers but also attracts other top talents.

For instance, consider Raj, a high-performing engineer who began to feel demotivated due to his company’s toxic culture. There was a lack of transparency, rampant office politics, and minimal support for personal growth. Raj eventually left for a company that prioritized a positive, collaborative work environment, where he could thrive and contribute more effectively.

Harnessing the Full Potential of High Performers

Managing high performers effectively requires a thoughtful and strategic approach. By avoiding the pitfalls of micromanagement, providing adequate challenges, offering regular recognition and feedback, and fostering a positive work environment, you can unlock the full potential of your top talent. Remember, high performers are not just resources to be managed; they are partners in achieving organizational success. Treat them with respect, support their growth, and watch them drive your team to new heights.

Implementing these strategies not only enhances the performance and satisfaction of your high performers but also sets a positive example for the entire team. By creating a supportive and empowering environment, you cultivate a culture of excellence and continuous improvement that benefits everyone.